The Contrast Between Christian and Pagan Lifestyles
By Phillip Schaff
The ancient world of classic pagandom, having arrived at the height of its
glory, and at the threshold of its decay, had exhausted all the resources of
human nature left to itself, and possessed no recuperative force, no
regenerative principle. A regeneration of society could only proceed from
religion. But the pagan religion had no restraint for vice, no comfort for
the poor and oppressed; it was itself the muddy fountain of immorality.
God, therefore, who in his infinite mercy desired not the destruction but
the salvation of the race, opened in the midst of this hopeless decay of a
false religion a pure fountain of holiness, love, and peace, in the only true
and universal religion of his Son Jesus Christ.
In the cheerless waste of pagan corruption the small and despised band of
Christians was an oasis fresh with life and hope. It was the salt of the earth,
and the light of the world. Poor in this world’s goods, it bore the
imperishable treasures of’ the kingdom of heaven. Meek and lowly in heart,
it was destined, according to the promise of the Lord without a stroke of
the sword, to inherit the earth. In submission it conquered; by suffering and
death it won the crown of life.
The superiority of the principles of Christian ethics over the pagan
standards of morality even under its most favorable forms is universally
admitted. The superiority of the example of Christ over all the pagan
sages is likewise admitted. The power of that peerless example was and is
now as great as the power of his teaching. It is reflected in every age and
every type of purity and goodness. But every period, while it shares in the
common virtues and graces, has its peculiar moral physiognomy. The ante-
Nicene age excelled in unworldliness, in the heroic endurance of suffering
and persecution, in the contempt of death, and the hope of resurrection, in
the strong sense of community, and in active benevolence.
Christianity, indeed, does not come “with observation.” Its deepest
workings are silent and inward. The operations of divine grace commonly
shun the notice of the historian, and await their revelation on the great day
of account, when all that is secret shall be made known. Who can measure
the depth and breadth of all those blessed experiences of forgiveness,
peace, gratitude, trust in God, love for God and love for man, humility and
meekness, patience and resignation, which have bloomed as vernal flowers
on the soil of the renewed heart since the first Christian Pentecost? Who
can tell the number and the fervor of Christian prayers and intercessions
which have gone up from lonely chambers, caves, deserts, and martyrs’
graves in the silent night and the open day, for friends and foes, for all
classes of mankind, even for cruel persecutors, to the throne of the exalted
Saviour? But where this Christian life has taken root in the depths of the
soul it must show itself in the outward conduct, and exert an elevating
influence on every calling and sphere of action. The Christian morality
surpassed all that the noblest philosophers of pagandom had ever taught
or labored for as the highest aim of man. The masterly picture of it in the
anonymous Epistle to Diognetus is no mere fancy sketch, but a faithful
copy from real life.
When the apologists indignantly repel the pagan calumnies, and
confidently point to the unfeigned piety, the brotherly love, the love for
enemies, the purity and chastity, the faithfulness and integrity, the patience
and gentleness, of the confessors of the name of Jesus, they speak from
daily experience and personal observation. “We, who once served lust,”
could Justin Martyr say without exaggeration, “now find our delight only
in pure morals; we, who once followed sorcery, have now consecrated
ourselves to the eternal good God; we, who once loved gain above all,
now give up what we have for the common use, and share with every
needy one; we, who once hated and killed each other; we, who would have
no common hearth with foreigners for difference of customs, now, since
the appearance of Christ, live with them, pray for our enemies, seek to
convince those who hate us without cause, that they may regulate their life
according to the glorious teaching of Christ, and receive from the all-ruling
God the same blessings with ourselves.” Tertullian could boast that he
knew no Christians who suffered by the hand of the executioner, except for
their religion. Minutius Felix tells the pagans601: “You prohibit adultery
by law, and practise it in secret; you punish wickedness only in the overt
act; we look upon it as criminal even in thought. You dread the inspection
of others; we stand in awe of nothing but our own consciences as becomes
Christians. And finally your prisons are overflowing with criminals; but
they are all pagans, not a Christian is there, unless he be an apostate.”
Even Pliny informed Trajan, that the Christians, whom he questioned on
the rack respecting the character of their religion, had bound themselves by
an oath never to commit theft, robbery, nor adultery, nor to break their
word and this, too at a time when the sins of fraud, uncleanness and
lasciviousness of every form abounded all around. Another pagan,
Lucian, bears testimony to their benevolence and charity for their brethren
in distress, while he attempts to ridicule this virtue as foolish weakness in
an age of unbounded selfishness.
The humble and painful condition of the church under civil oppression
made hypocrisy more rare than in times of peace, and favored the
development of the heroic virtues. The Christians delighted to regard
themselves as soldiers of Christ, enlisted under the victorious standard of
the cross against sin, the world, and the devil. The baptismal vow was their
oath of perpetual allegiance;602 the Apostles’ creed their parole;603 the sign
of the cross upon the forehead, their mark of service;604 temperance,
courage, and faithfulness unto death, their cardinal virtues; the blessedness
of heaven, their promised reward. “No soldier,” exclaims Tertullian to the
Confessors, “goes with his sports or from his bed-chamber to the battle;
but from the camp, where he hardens and accustoms himself to every
inconvenience. Even in peace warriors learn to bear labor and fatigue,
going through all military exercises, that neither soul nor body may flag ....
Ye wage a good warfare, in which the living God is the judge of the
combat, the Holy Spirit the leader, eternal glory the prize.” To this may be
added the eloquent passage of Minutius Felix605: “How fair a spectacle in
the sight of God is a Christian entering the lists with affliction, and with
noble firmness combating menaces and tortures, or with a disdainful smile
marching to death through the clamors of the people, and the insults of the
executioners; when he bravely maintains his liberty against kings and
princes, and submits to God, whose servant he is; when, like a conqueror,
he triumphs over the judge that condemns him. For he certainly is
victorious who obtains what he fights for. He fights under the eye of God,
and is crowned with length of days. You have exalted some of your stoical
sufferers to the skies; such as Scaevola who, having missed his aim in an
attempt to kill the king voluntarily burned the mistaking hand. Yet how
many among us have suffered not only the hand, but the whole body to be
consumed without a complaint, when their deliverance was in their own
power! But why should I compare our elders with your Mutius, or
Aquilius, or Regulus, when our very children, our sons and daughters,
inspired with patience, despise your racks and wild beasts, and all other
instruments of cruelty? Surely nothing but the strongest reasons could
persuade people to suffer at this rate; and nothing else but Almighty power
could support them under their sufferings.”
Yet, on the other hand, the Christian life of the period before Constantine
has been often unwarrantably idealized. In a human nature essentially the
same, we could but expect the same faults which we found even in the
apostolic churches. The Epistles of Cyprian afford incontestable evidence,
that, especially in the intervals of repose, an abatement of zeal soon
showed itself, and, on the reopening of persecution, the Christian name
was dishonored by hosts of apostates. And not seldom did the most
prominent virtues, courage in death, and strictness of morals, degenerate
into morbid fanaticism and unnatural rigor.
THE CHURCH AND PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS.
Christianity is anything but sanctimonious gloominess and misanthropic
austerity. It is the fountain of true joy, and of that peace which “passeth all
understanding.” But this joy wells up from the consciousness of pardon
and of fellowship with God, is inseparable from holy earnestness, and has
no concord with worldly frivolity and sensual amusement, which carry the
sting of a bad conscience, and beget only disgust and bitter remorse. “What
is more blessed,” asks Tertullian, “than reconciliation with God our Father
and Lord; than the revelation of the truth, the knowledge of error; than the
forgiveness of so great past misdeeds? Is there a greater joy than the
disgust with earthly pleasure, than contempt for the whole world, than true
freedom, than an unstained conscience, than contentment in life and
fearlessness in death?”
Contrast with this the popular amusements of the pagan: the theatre, the
circus, and the arena. They were originally connected with the festivals of
the gods, but had long lost their religious character and degenerated into
nurseries of vice. The theatre, once a school of public morals in the best
days of Greece, when Aeschylos and Sophocles furnished the plays, had
since the time of Augustus room only for low comedies and unnatural
tragedies, with splendid pageantry, frivolous music, and licentious
dances.606 Tertullian represents it as the temple of Venus and Bacchus,
who are close allies as patrons of lust and drunkenness.
The circus was devoted to horse and chariot races, hunts of wild beasts, military displays
and athletic games, and attracted immense multitudes. “The impatient
crowd,” says the historian of declining Rome608 “rushed at the dawn of day
to secure their places, and there were many who passed a sleepless and
anxious night in the adjacent porticos. From the morning to the evening
careless of the sun or of the rain, the spectators, who sometimes amounted
to the number of four hundred thousand, remained in eager attention; their
eyes fixed on the horses and charioteers, their minds agitated with hope
and fear for the success of the colors which they espoused; and the
happiness of Rome appeared to hang on the event of a race. The same
immoderate ardor inspired their clamors and their applause as often as they
were entertained with the hunting of wild beasts and the various modes of
theatrical representation.”
The most popular, and at the same time the most inhuman and brutalizing
of these public spectacles were the gladiatorial fights in the arena. There
murder was practised as an art, from sunrise to sunset, and myriads of men
and beasts were sacrificed to satisfy a savage curiosity and thirst for blood.
At the inauguration of the Flavian amphitheatre from five to nine thousand
wild beasts (according to different accounts) were slain in one day. No less
than ten thousand gladiators fought in the feasts which Trajan gave to the
Romans after the conquest of Dacia, and which lasted four months (A.D.
107). Under Probus (A.D. 281) as many as a hundred lions, a hundred
lionesses, two hundred leopards, three hundred bears, and a thousand wild
boars were massacred in a single day.
The contrast between the pagan and Christian lifestyles was one of the main factors leading to the rapid spread of Christianity, as explained further in the article, Rise of Christianity.